Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence

Go down

Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence Empty Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence

Post by Seattleite on Tue Jun 11, 2013 5:18 am

As some of you might agree, Konami sucks. Their rulings on Xyzs deattaching are so weird, they had to make a new term called "limbo". Limbo is neither on the field nor off the field. Cards like Reborn Tengu don't activate when overlayed or deattached. Dandylion doesn't make tokens when it's "sent to the graveyard" when deattached, even though common sense would tell you otherwise.

Anyway, should we change the rulings on this? We could consider being in "limbo" either explicitly on or off the field, and have effects that trigger when removed from the field activate at that time.

What u think?

_________________
Ice Cube takes all your moms to prom

BEES:
Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence Oprahs-Bees
Seattleite
Seattleite
Admin

Posts : 2290
Join date : 2010-10-27
Age : 25
Location : Seattle, WA

http://duelportal.tk

Back to top Go down

Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence Empty Re: Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence

Post by DIGITAL on Tue Jun 11, 2013 7:03 am

When the cards are underlaid they are no longer considered themselves, but part of the Xyz monster they are a material of. Therefore being detached doesn't remove the monster from the field. It removes a part of the Xyz.
Konami is correct IMO.
DIGITAL
DIGITAL

Posts : 1067
Join date : 2011-03-18

Back to top Go down

Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence Empty Re: Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence

Post by Ash on Tue Jun 11, 2013 9:35 am

dandylion does make tokens and the ruling and idea makes complete sense. things like heraldic beast leo, dandylion and tour bus all activate when sent to the graveyard under any circumstance, even if detached.

and like soulfire already said, the tengu "off the field" ruling is also clear

there is no real difficulty or ruling dispute present

_________________
rumbler tumbler is the best card
>whenever i read a card made by emsoup
>Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence Tumblr_lz2w42NI6E1qii6tmo1_400
Ash
Ash

Posts : 1484
Join date : 2010-12-10
Age : 25
Location : Hull, England

Back to top Go down

Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence Empty Re: Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence

Post by Illgresi on Tue Jun 11, 2013 5:03 pm

Ash wrote:dandylion does make tokens and the ruling and idea makes complete sense. things like heraldic beast leo, dandylion and tour bus all activate when sent to the graveyard under any circumstance, even if detached

If that's the case, I have no problems with that limbo thingy
Illgresi
Illgresi

Posts : 230
Join date : 2011-05-31
Age : 24
Location : Here.

Back to top Go down

Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence Empty Re: Xyzs and Konami's Incompetence

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum